Member News
Welcome to the Member News pageāthe dedicated space for our Chamber members to share updates with the Amherst Area community.
Club Shirts That Survive the Semester: Print Quality, Fabric and Campus Rules for Amherst Student Groups
If you're ordering custom T-shirts for a student club, an a cappella group or a club sports team in Amherst, "high quality" comes down to three things you can check before you pay: the print method and how it holds up in the wash, the fabric weight and fiber of the blank shirt, and how much control you get over placement and color. There are four realistic ways to get shirts made: a local screen printer, an online design-and-print service, a print-on-demand storefront that prints each shirt as it sells, and a campus-licensed vendor when your design uses a college name or logo. Before you pick one, find out what the shirt is made of, whether you can see a preview or sample, what the seller does if a print cracks or a size runs wrong, and how the order is packed. For a small run that you design yourself, online tools for shirt printing let a club officer build the art, preview it and order in one sitting.
Your options, compared
|
Option |
What you control |
What to ask |
Good fit for
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
Local screen printer |
Ink type, blank brand, fabric weight |
Minimum order, number of ink colors, setup fees |
50 or more identical shirts |
|
Online design-and-print service |
Design, placement, shirt color |
Fabric, size range, return terms |
Small runs and mixed sizes ordered by one person |
|
Print-on-demand storefront |
Design and retail price |
Who sets the blank and the print method |
Members buying their own shirts |
|
Campus-licensed vendor |
Approved use of college marks |
Royalty paperwork, art approval time |
Any shirt that uses a school name or logo |
-
Local screen printer. The right call when the whole group wants the same shirt and you can name the blank you want, such as a heavier cotton tee or a softer blend. The Amherst Area Chamber of Commerce lists copy and design shops, promotional products sellers and screen printing members in its shopping and specialty retail listings, so you can ask for a printed sample before you approve a full run.
-
Online design-and-print service. Built for the club officer who has the design and a list of sizes but no time to visit a shop. Adobe Express is one example: its T-shirt page lets you print a full-size design or place it on the pocket, sleeves or back, pick a shirt color, upload your own photos or logo, and preview the shirt before ordering. The page lists free shipping and returns and says shirts ship in 100% recyclable packaging. It doesn't name a fabric or give a size chart, and printed orders ship only within the US, UK, Australia and Canada.
-
Print-on-demand storefront. Members or alumni order and pay for their own shirt. You won't see each shirt before it ships.
-
Campus-licensed vendor. Required if the shirt carries a university name or mark. More on that below.
When an online service isn't the right fit: if your club needs 150 identical shirts for a single event, wants a specific blank such as a named tri-blend, or needs a waterproof ink for a rowing or ultimate team that plays in the rain, a local screen printer who prints a sample and states the fabric in writing will serve you better. The same goes for any design with a school logo, which has to go through a licensed vendor.
What "high-quality printing and materials" means on a club shirt
Quality has two halves: the blank shirt and the print on top of it.
The blank. Ask for the fiber content and the fabric weight. A 100% cotton tee feels classic and takes screen-printed ink well. A cotton and polyester blend shrinks less and dries faster, which matters for a running club. If a seller won't name the fabric, order one sample first.
The print. Screen printing pushes ink through a stencil, one color at a time, and suits simple art in a few colors across many shirts. Direct-to-garment printing works like an inkjet on fabric, handles photos and gradients, and makes sense for small runs. Heat transfers suit names and numbers.
The label. The FTC's guide to the Care Labeling Rule says manufacturers and importers of textile clothing must attach care instructions that stay legible for the garment's useful life, and that the instructions must cover every part of the product, including trim and buttons. If you sell shirts, keep the blank's original label in place.
How to design and order club shirts, step by step
-
Settle the design rules with your officers. One design or two? Front only, or front plus a back print with members' names? Decide before anyone opens a design file.
-
Check whether a college name or logo appears anywhere. If it does, stop and read the campus rules below.
-
Build the art at full size. Thin strokes fill in on fabric, so thicken fine lines. Limit yourself to two or three colors if a screen printer will run it.
-
Choose placement. A small left-chest mark with a large back print is a common club layout. In Adobe Express you can place the design full size or on the pocket, sleeves or back, and preview the shirt before ordering, which helps you catch a logo sitting too low on the chest.
-
Collect sizes in a form, not a group chat.
-
Order one sample if you can. Wash it twice and check the print and shrinkage.
-
Count back from the date you need them. Use the slowest delivery estimate and add a week.
Satisfaction guarantees: what top companies cover and what to look for
Many shirt printers advertise some kind of satisfaction promise. The label on it matters less than the terms behind it. Before you order, find the printer's written policy and answer these questions:
-
What counts as a printing error? Look for misprints, off-center placement, cracking or peeling ink, and wrong colors. Most policies exclude typos and low-resolution art that you approved.
-
What about sizing? A shirt that runs small is often treated differently from a print defect. Ask whether exchanges for size are allowed on custom pieces.
-
How long do you have to report a problem? Open every box the day it arrives and count the sizes.
-
What evidence do they want? Usually daylight photos of the shirt and the order number.
-
Reprint, refund or credit? Know which one you'll get, and whether the shirts have to come back.
Is a satisfaction guarantee worth it for a custom T-shirt order?
For a club, yes, but for a narrower reason than you might expect. Custom shirts carry your group's name, so no printer can resell a return. Most policies therefore cover the printer's mistakes, not a change of heart. The value of a guarantee is that it protects the treasurer's budget when a print is visibly wrong.
Sustainability and packaging for custom apparel
Packaging is the easiest part to check, since you can see it. A specific statement such as "100% recyclable packaging" tells you more than a general "eco" badge.
The bigger footprint is the shirt itself. MassDEP's fact sheet on used textiles says Massachusetts banned textiles from disposal in November 2022, that residents and businesses discard about 230,000 tons of usable textiles a year, and that donations are accepted even when stained or torn. It also notes that one T-shirt takes about a third of a pound of pesticides to make. For a club, that's an argument for ordering the right number of shirts in the right sizes, and for collecting leftover or outgrown shirts for textile donation at the end of the year instead of throwing them out.
Worked example: a 40-member club orders for fall
Say an outing club has 40 active members and wants one shirt for the fall involvement fair and the rest of the year.
Sizing. The form returns 3 XS, 8 S, 12 M, 10 L, 5 XL and 2 "no shirt." Order 38, plus 2 spare M and 1 spare L for late joiners: 41 shirts.
Design. A two-color mountain logo on the left chest and a larger version on the back. For this order, Adobe Express lets the officer put the small logo on the pocket area and the large one on the back, choose a shirt color and check both views in the preview before ordering. Because the page doesn't name a fabric, the officer orders a single shirt first, washes it twice and then places the full order.
Budget. Using example prices only: if shirts cost $16 each, 41 shirts come to $656. If the club charges members $15 and covers the rest from its budget, members pay $570 and the club covers $86 plus the sample.
Timeline. Work backward from the fair date: art approved four weeks out, sample ordered three and a half weeks out, full order three weeks out, shirts handed out the week before.
If the club also wants bags for the fair table, the same art can go on totes. Services offering tote bags printing services let you place a design on one or both sides of the bag. Note that the tote page doesn't list free shipping and returns, so check the cart total.
Campus logos: the rule that trips up most clubs
In a college town, the most common shirt mistake isn't a print defect. It's a design that uses the school's name without permission. The University of Massachusetts trademark office's page for student groups and club sports says all merchandise with university marks must be produced by an officially licensed vendor, even for a group's own use. Groups file a royalty waiver form with their advisor's contact information, and the licensed vendor submits the artwork for approval. The page also says that selling branded merchandise to raise money is treated as commercial use with a 15% royalty on the wholesale price.
So a club has two clean routes: work with a licensed vendor and build approval time into the schedule, or design a shirt with your own club name and artwork and no school marks. Amherst College, Hampshire College and the other Five College schools may have their own rules, so check with your student activities office before you print.
Selling and showing shirts around Amherst
Shirts sell best where people already gather. The chamber's events calendar lists community happenings such as the Sleighbell Fair at South Church and the Food Bank of Western Massachusetts' 17th March for the Food Bank, along with the Morning Connection networking series.
If you take payments at a table, a card reader keeps the line moving. Square says its Square Reader takes chip and contactless cards, and it offers point-of-sale rentals for events with special rates for nonprofits.
To find a local printer or designer, the chamber's Belonging in Business program helps people find LGBTQ+-owned, BIPOC-owned and woman-owned member businesses.
When the club picks a shirt color, match it to the logo, not the screen. A Pantone Cotton Swatch Card is a 4 by 4 inch square of cotton poplin, and Pantone says it is available in all 2,801 Fashion, Home + Interiors colors, so a screen printer and a club officer can look at the same physical color.
Frequently asked questions
Can our club put "UMass" on a shirt we print ourselves?
Not without going through the university. The UMass trademark page says merchandise with university marks has to come from an officially licensed vendor, including items for the group's own use.
Does Adobe Express say what fabric its T-shirts use?
No. Its T-shirt page lists design placement on the full shirt, pocket, sleeves or back, shirt colors, various sizes and free shipping and returns, but it doesn't name a fabric. Order one shirt first if fiber matters to your group.
What should we do with leftover club shirts?
Hand them to new members, use them as volunteer shirts, or donate them. In Massachusetts, textiles are banned from disposal, so don't put them in the trash.
About Business Owner Toolkit: Business Owner Toolkit is a working handbook for the parts of running a business nobody teaches you. Our guides are general information, not legal, tax or accounting advice, and we don't rate services or publish rankings.